Potty Training: How to Avoid the Battle

November 2011

Bookmark and Share  

  • As a professional nanny of 26 years, I have potty “trained” many children, 23 to be exact. Or rather, as a young nanny, they “trained” me.

  • Mistakes I made and learned from:

  • 1. Avoid the use of rewards, gifts or candy after the child performs the desired result. Put away the sticker charts and M&Ms. They are bribes and children know it. It can easily become a power struggle, which you want to avoid. It is their body and their decision. You cannot control it. Let it go! I had one boy who was not potty trained until he was four-and-a-half because the rewards had to be bigger and better every time!

  • 2. Not waiting until full readiness: I do not advise beginning this process before the age of two-and-a-half. Boys are often closer to three years. It is likely to fail and there is a greater chance of regression.

  • 3. Girls mostly decide on their own. I have found that it’s easier to let it go and let them decide when, where and how. Forget pull-ups. Too much like a diaper.

  • 4. Do not potty train when there is a new baby in the house or any other big life changes such as a move, new preschool, illness, etc. Again, they will likely regress.

  • 5. Avoid silly videos. Enough said. I can still hear “You are a super dooper pooper….you can potty like the best…”

  • 6. Books can help somewhat in the process, but keep it simple.

  • 7. Remember to look at it from the child’s point of view: It is so much easier to go in this diaper than it is to run to the bathroom, figure out the pants, take them down, sit down, etc.

  • 8. No shame, blame or pain. Again, this will likely cause a power struggle.

  • 9. Grandma may say you were potty trained at nine months, but their memory is likely faulty. Sorry, Grandma!

  • 10. Let them own the process. Truly. Use lots of encouragement not praise.

  • The Big How To’s:

  • 1. Choose a time when you can mostly be home for a few days.

  • 2. It’s easier during warm weather—they can pee in the grass. Bring a small potty with you everywhere in the house so it’s close by. I like Baby Bjorn.

  • 3. I would talk about how she/he is going to learn to go peepee and poopoo in the potty.

  • 4. Hide the diapers and say, “Uh Oh! We’re all out.”

  • 5. Ask them if they would like to wear underwear (previously picked out at Target with him/her) or nothing at all. (limited choice)

  • 6. Make it fun! We’re going to do this today! It’s exciting!

  • 7. You may encounter a bit of resistance at first, which is normal. Sorry, diapers all gone!

  • 8. If there’s an accident, act like it’s no big deal. Next time you can try again.

  • 9. Clean up the mess together, unless it’s a B.M. Urine is sterile.

  • 10. No Baby Guess pants with zippers, snaps, etc. Just a plain, easy-to-remove elastic waist band on the pants. At least for the beginning learning.

  • 11. Relax, know it’s their process. Do not compare your child with others. I don’t know any child who went to college in diapers. Although I have wondered about a few boys—I envisioned them drinking beer, watching sports and just peeing in their adult-size diapers.

  • by Susan Lehman who is a Certified Nanny, C.P.D.T. (Certified Positive Discipline Trainer) and Parenting Coach. www.solutionswithsusan.weebly.com You may mail her at solutionswithsusan@gmail.com (650)521-4359

    .